
“Some of us dive and some of us snorkel. Which island should we choose?”
It’s a question we hear often at Punta Cana Scuba Diving, and our recommendation is usually Saona. Both islands offer diving, snorkeling, and beach time, but the experience is quite different.
Here’s how we help our guests choose.
Catalina: A Beautiful Beach and The Wall
In our opinion, Catalina has the most beautiful beach of the two islands. If your group loves spending time on the sand, it deserves consideration.
Our first stop is The Wall, where a shallow reef meets a dramatic drop-off reaching approximately 30 meters. Divers explore below at depths suited to their experience, while our snorkelers enjoy the reef from the surface with our guide.
Once on the island, you can snorkel from the beach or explore a hiking trail leading to a platform where, when access and conditions permit, you can jump into the sea and snorkel back.
There are two things to consider, though: the crossing and the crowds.
The route crosses deep, exposed water and can be quite choppy, particularly in the afternoon. We recommend an early start. Catalina also receives cruise ship visitors, so the beach can become crowded during high season something many of our private charter guests prefer to avoid.

Saona: Our Favorite for Divers and Snorkelers
The Saona route generally offers calmer waters and a wonderful combination of reefs, island time, and shallow-water swimming.
The Peñon sites we visit on this trip are among the best reefs in our area, making Saona our recommendation for the diving as well as the overall day. We choose our dive sites according to our divers’ experience and the conditions.
Our snorkelers have plenty to enjoy, too. At Punto de gran rayo, our guides help them explore waters home to giant southern stingrays and hawksbill turtles. Sightings are never guaranteed, but these encounters are among our favorite moments to share with guests.
Yes, we stop on Isla Saona itself, giving beach lovers time to enjoy the shore. But for many guests, the highlight comes at our final stop: Starfish Cay.

Starfish Cay: Where Everyone Comes Together
Crystal-clear, waist-deep water stretches around our boat. You can swim, stand, chat, and enjoy the Caribbean together.
This is where we normally anchor for shallow-water swimming after our underwater adventures. If you add our chef service, it is also where we normally prepare your meal onboard.
It’s a beautiful place to bring everyone together after exploring the reefs, whether they spent their morning diving or snorkeling.
How Does a Trip with Divers and Snorkelers Work?
On both itineraries, our first dive and guided snorkeling take place at the same site. Everyone explores at their own level, with our dive and snorkel guides looking after their respective groups.
For the second dive, our snorkelers generally head to the beach with our guide while our divers continue their underwater adventure.
Many of our divers are happy to trade some beach time for longer dives. A private charter lets us discuss those preferences beforehand and plan around your group, with dive times always subject to air consumption and safe diving limits.
What If Your Group Mostly Wants Beaches?
If diving is less of a priority and your group wants more beach time, ask us about our Four Beaches Tour on Saona.
It’s another option worth considering before choosing Catalina simply for its beach. We can help you decide whether a dive-and-snorkel itinerary or a day focused on exploring Saona’s beaches better suits your group.
A Few Practical Questions
Our Recommendation
- Choose Catalina if its beautiful beach and The Wall appeal most, keeping the potential for choppy crossings and cruise ship crowds in mind.
- Choose Saona for some of our best reef diving, guided snorkeling, an island beach stop, and time together at Starfish Cay.
- Tell us how many guests will dive, how many will snorkel, and where you are staying. Our crew will help you plan a private day everyone can look forward to.
